Friday, December 07, 2007

Kindle Review for the Masie Consortium 

I've had an Amazon Kindle for a week now. In fact, I've even read a book already and passed it on to friends and colleagues to get their feedback.

It was kind of cool to get the jump on folks like ZDNet and have real Amazon Kindle review done by last Monday. Their "initial impressions" reviews just showed up in my inbox today. However, last Monday, Elliott Masie shared his take on the Kindle in a video posted for the Masie Learning Consortium and also posted a PDF of my review. Recently the same material was also shared with the broader learning community via the Learning TRENDS Newsletter he publishes. Here's a quote from the December 5, 2007 entry:

Kindle Reader from Amazon - Perspectives: We have been testing the new Kindle Reader device recently released by Amazon. This is the latest in a series of e-book readers that we have seen and reviewed at The MASIE Center. While the new device has some flaws and usability challenges (including the absence of a touch screen), it is an important "baby step" towards the dream of more accessible digital content. Just as Apple's iPod and the iTunes site popularized the concept of buying and downloading a song for a dollar, Kindle is aimed at doing the same for books. Our Learning CONSORTIUM will be doing a series of experiments with the Kindle and other e-Readers to see how they could best be integrated into corporate learning. You can take a peek at our work by going to http://www.masieweb.com/kindle.

Elliott has a nice 6 minute video overview on the page at the link above, which also has a link to a PDF that he has referred to as, "[Tom King has done] a more technical, in-depth "first look" at content models for the Kindle as well as human factor issues." Cool and not even entirely self-promotion for me. :-)

Speaking of promotion, if you plan to purchase a Kindle, please consider using the link below so that I will receive an Amazon Associates referral fee. Thanks.

Kindle: Amazon's New Wireless Reading Device

Labels: , ,


Comments:
Excellent review. Thanks Tom. Don't you think the aesthetics of the thing are atrocious? It looks like some cheap fake kid's "computer" you'd find in a blister pack at Walmart.

I'll pass on the link to purchase. I was hoping to participate in Tom King's "give one, get one" program for the Kindle. Burtonia has a shockingly low per capita income, and we appreciate donated technology!
 
You'll appreciate that I soft-peddled some of my disdain for their choice of polymer resins (did you catch the reference?).

Adrian Kingsley-Hughes has largely worn-out his welcome with me, he is too hyphenated and curmudgeonly. Here he might have a point though on 'Cult of Kindle'
http://blogs.zdnet.com/hardware/?p=1023

Then again another bloggeratti member went quite venomous in video. It's actual fun to watch see the video below the text rant.
http://scobleizer.com/2007/11/25/dear-jeff-bezos-one-week-kindle-review/
 
Tom - Excellent review. I find a great deal of potential in the Kindle in a number of areas. I think with a few software updates and the ability to write some custom content this could be a good machine (consider being able to put DITA documents on this thing...). Your assessment that this would be a good procedural reference device is spot on.

What I really like is the ability to get books at a cheaper cost than the physical version as well as newspapers and magazines. I'd like to see a larger selection of magazines and newspapers, but I suppose that will come in time. Of course I am one of those folks that like a physical magazine so it could be that I don't use that too often anyhow.

I have used the MobiPocket software to convert some PDF files I had and it worked fairly well. Some of the content didn't convert as well as I would've hoped, but I did convert some of the SCORM documentation with fairly decent results.

I'm not as concerned with the looks of the machine. While I agree with your assessment that the 'Next Page'/'Previous Page' buttons do have an unfortunate placement, I've come to accept the "Hey look at me! I've got the retro stylings of an Apple IIc!" feel of the thing.
 
This came out from our firm today regarding security on Kindle

"While, by all accounts, the Kindle is a great way to enjoy e-books and other material, note that it does not include security to protect the contents. If you buy or receive one as a gift, you should not use it (or any other device without password and encryption technology) to hold firm or client information.

So while you enjoy your Kindle to read e-books, beware not to let a data security breach spoil your holiday season."
 
Post a Comment

External links to this post:

Create a Link


Views I express on this weblog are mine, period. My views and opinions do not necessarily reflect the views of my employer, my clients or anyone else for that matter. My opinions are my own.

Copyright © 2004-2007 Tom King

This page is powered by Blogger. Isn't yours?        Feedblitz- Subscribe and get your updates by email